Color Matching a Canon C300 to an Arri Alexa
They said it couldn't be done. Maybe, but I got close. How close? You judge...
By Art Adams | January 26, 2013
First, the standard disclaimer:
While I plan on using these settings myself for future projects, your mileage may differ depending on a number of factors including taste, camera software version, lens choices, etc. As a result I take no responsibility if you don't like the results. It's up to you to test these settings before you use them professionally to make sure they work to your satisfaction. By using these settings you indemnify me against any claims in the event that someone down the road doesn't like how these settings look and that costs you money.
If everybody loves you as a result of these settings I'm happy to bask in the glow of your success.
NOTE: As I mentioned in an update to the front page, I received some complaints saying that the daylight matrix made reds look blueish on some cameras. I came up with a replacement daylight matrix while shooting with a C300 the other day so I've replaced the original settings below. I hope to have a new version of both matrices, version 2, posted by sometime next week that should work well on C100s, C300s and C500s.
Here they are:

Detail circuit settings are not included. When we compared camera detail we discovered that setting the C300 detail circuit to its lowest value resulted in an image that was still sharper than the Alexa. Adjust it to your own taste.
As color and gamma are completely decoupled in the C300 you can use this matrix with any gamma, although be sure to test this first to make sure the results are to your liking. I like Cinema1 and Cinema2 myself.
Don't use these matrix settings with any matrix other than EOS Standard as you will get untested, unintended and unpredictable results.
One last very, very important note:
THESE SETTINGS WILL NOT TURN YOUR CANON C300 INTO AN ARRI ALEXA REPLACEMENT. I've attempted to replicate aspects of the Alexa's colorimetry in a camera whose design and color science are completely different in every way, using very coarse tools whose settings sit on top of Canon's proprietary color science. The C300 doesn't have the subtlety of color that Alexa offers, nor can it match Alexa's dynamic range, and it doesn't duplicate that delicate Alexa softness that makes everyone and everything look great. On the other hand, the C300 is less expensive and much smaller and lighter, and is the perfect tool for certain projects.
If you own a Canon C300, if you can only afford a C300, if you need the mobility and size of a C300, use a C300. If you can afford an Arri Alexa, use the Alexa. Get the right tool for the right job.
You can download a PDF version of the settings here.
Thanks very much to Adam Wilt for his time and help, and to Chater Camera (especially Jay and Charlie) for allowing me playtime with their gear.
Disclosure: I have worked as a paid consultant to DSC Labs. If you're interested in their charts, check out their website and read my article about their new film-style HD grading chart.
Art Adams | Director of Photography & Motion Picture Technology Consultant | 01/26/13 | www.artadamsdp.com
Page 3 of 3 pages « Previous 1 2 3
Share This
Get articles like this in your inbox: Sign Up
Comments
Twitter Feed
-
editblog - Sat, May 25 2013 - 9:56 am
RT @craigaw1969: At Heathrow wirelessly editing footage on ISIS in Germany using @Avid @MediaComposer & Interplay Sphere #postchat http://t.co/ZPGphL7RHk -
editblog - Sat, May 25 2013 - 9:46 am
@jonnyelwyn no you shouldn't. But those should be backed up anyway right?





.jpg)

Rob von Münchhofen: | January, 29, 2013
Hi Art
Thanks for that - I always enjoy reading your tests and articles.
I’m preparing for a one day commercial shoot with the c300 right now and I do have a question regarding this article and another one, you wrote nearly one year ago, in which you describe how to get rid of the green tint in the WB presets by using the WB Gain under the C300s custom menu. The article is accessible here: http://provideocoalition.com/aadams/story/canon_c300_trimming_white_balance_plus_a_look_at_daylight_vs._tungsten_colo/
Now as you clearly point out above, this here is the attempt to match the C300 as closely as possible to the Alexa. Both Cameras have got some sort of green shift in their preset whites.
So am i right in assuming that in the case of matching both cameras by using the color matrix, you did NOT include any kind of anti green shifting?
Is it possible to use your matrix settings (as above) and also on top of that make adjustments in the WB gain of the camera to get a clearer white under tungsten and daylight respectively, without weighting any colors?
I am really looking forward to your answer and testing your matrix settings.
Thank you
Brian C. Weed: | February, 01, 2013
Thanks for your incredible work on this, Art. One question - would it help to use the C300’s Color Corrector CP setting to tame the reds back a bit instead of decreasing overall saturation? Could that also be used to boost the cyans a bit, since there are A & B options?
Art Adams: | February, 03, 2013
Hi Robert- I sent you a note privately about this as your comment hadn’t shown up yet here when I was notified of it, but within a month or two of my reporting that green white balance issue I played with a C300 at NAB and it was gone. They’d apparently fixed it with a software update. That’s one of the fastest responses I’ve ever seen from a camera company. It white balances perfectly now.
Hi Brian- Interesting idea, but I get a little nervous using secondary color correction for something this basic. Sometimes unexpected things happen because you’re bending one part of the color response in a way that’s inconsistent with the rest. It works great for product shots but I worry about doing it for everything.
This “bending” is what happens internally already if you look at the range between green and cyan on any of the other color matrices and it looks a bit strange. I’m going to try to tweak some more on these matrices later this week and I’ll give this a try when I do.
Hi Peong- No problem, it’s what I do for fun. I’m such a geek.
It’s fun being my own lab.
If anyone has any comments about these matrices let me know, especially if you get any unexpected results. So far I’ve been fairly happy with them but there’ll be more tweaking and a version 2.0 sometime in the near future.
Please login or register to comment