HP DreamColor Mac connectivity & functionality: update 2012.1
By Allan Tépper | July 03, 2012
After a period of non-disclosure from HP, I finally have lots of information to report about news regarding DreamColor connectivity and functionality with Mac. In this article, you’ll find out about new DreamColor software for Mac (you no longer need temporary access to Microsoft Windows to calibrate the DreamColor in a pro video environment with a pro video i/o interface), problems and solutions resulting from Apple’s surprising switch to YUV instead of RGB on the Mini DisplayPort/Thunderbolt output on Macs released starting in 2011, and more. I have called this article DreamColor Mac connectivity and functionality: update 2012.1 because I expect there to be several more this year.
Prior DreamColor articles in ProVideo Coalition magazine
In the past few years, I have published at least nine related articles, and Art Adams and Patrick Inhofer have published related articles too. Many of those articles are kind of a prerequisite for this new article, and are listed and linked at the end of this article for those who may have missed them.
Ahead in this article
- New Mac calibration software for DreamColor
- General challenges for directly-connecting a critical video monitor to a computer for video editing or grading
- Solving framerate issues
- New problem caused by Apple’s Mini DisplayPort/Thunderbolt output gone YUV, and a few solutions
- Retina MacBook Pro’s new HDMI output: Is it kosher for DreamColor?
- Will AJA’s upcoming T-TAP be the messiah for the DreamColor (for those who otherwise don’t need a full i/o)?
New Mac calibration software for DreamColor
When you calibrate a DreamColor monitor connected to a professional i/o device from AJA, Blackmagic, Matrox, or MOTU, the settings and profiles are stored in the monitor (as they need to be), not in the computer. Up until now, it has been necessary for Mac-based editing/grading suites to have at least temporary access to Microsoft Windows in order to carry out such a calibration. This has meant bringing a Windows laptop or desktop temporarily into the edit/grading suite, or installing Windows under Boot Camp onto the Mac used in the editing or grading suite. (For me at least it only worked via Boot Camp. The only time I tried via a virtual machine, it didn’t work.)
Although the installer for the new Mac software has not yet hit the HP web site (they are in the midst of a redesign and it won't go live until the redesign rolls down to the product pages), it is available from X-Rite (as all DreamColor Calibration software is) here.
General challenges for directly-connecting a critical video monitor to a computer for video editing or grading
- The video editing or grading app needs to be able to deliver a trustable signal to the computer’s GPU. When I say trustable, I mean that the brightness, contrast, gamma, and color must be a faithful representation of the actual video being handled internally, even though color transcoding will often be necessary. This was absolutely not the case with FCP 6 or 7 (or Color) by Apple’s own admission in writing. That’s why with FCP 6 and 7 and Color, a professional i/o device was the only choice for critical evaluation. I have never received a straight answer about this with FCP X, and other issues you’ll read ahead have detoured me from determining it myself so far. At least I haven’t seen any warnings in writing from Apple about it not being trustable with FCP X the way I had before with FCP 6 and 7. Adobe began promising this capability starting with Premiere CS5 and presumably maintains this feature with Premiere CS6. I have heard from a credible source that this is also true with Avid Media Composer 6.
- The Mac’s OS must be able to deliver an appropriate raster to the monitor (i.e. 1920x1080 or in some cases I’ve covered previously (i.e. FCP X), 1920x1200).
- This is only good to monitor progressive video, not interlaced video (Not a problem for me or most people I know, but I realize that there are some people who love interlaced video. If you love interlaced video and also insist on monitoring interlaced video as-is, this is not for you. However, it certainly can be for you if you are in the process of converting some raw interlaced footage into progressive, knowing that your final deliverable will be progressive. Some people might call this “sanitizing” the raw interlaced video.)
- In order to have smooth playback and lip sync, the Mac must output a proper framerate to match the timeline/sequence/project settings (or at least a 2x representation of it), and this must be handled manually for each sequence/project/timeline if they change from one to the next. (Theoretically the software developer of the video editing/grading could request this of the GPU via the OS, but I haven’t seen that happen so far. Maybe it’s coming with Mountain Lion…) More about this in the next section below.
Solving framerate issues
Ideally, we should be able to send the DreamColor the exact framerate that is on the timeline/sequence/project, or a 2x representation of them for the slower ones, since the DreamColor does a 2x of them anyway. The exact doubling should not introduce any frame-rate conversion artifacts. So:
- 23.976p sequences/projects/timelines should be sent at 23.976 Hz or 47.952 Hz.
- 24.000p sequences/projects/timelines should be sent at 24.000 Hz or 48.000 Hz
- 25p sequences/projects/timelines should be sent at 25.000 Hz or 50.000 Hz
- 29.97p sequences/projects/timelines should be sent at 29.970 Hz or 59.94 Hz
- 50p sequences/projects/timelines should be sent at 50 Hz
- 59.94p sequences/projects/timelines should be sent at 59.94 Hz
The DreamColor can accept all of those listed. The behavior of the Mac OS varies among versions and the hardware surrounding it, as well as the monitor connected to it. Hopefully, when you connect your Mac to your DreamColor, the Mac’s Display control panel (inside of the System Preferences) will offer you the correct matching framerate (or at a least 2x representation, as listed above). If that is not the case, you may need a third-party piece of software in order to add options to the control panel. One that I have successfully used is SwitchResX. However, you must use it at your own risk. I have used it at least twice on two different systems, and it has never caused me any problems, but I have heard of a case where someone had to reinstall his entire operating system. The last time I used it was in 2011 and it was compatible with 10.7.x. Its GUI isn’t the friendliest, but it did accomplish what the goal was: to add 50Hz to the Mac’s Display control panel.
New problem caused by Apple’s Mini DisplayPort/Thunderbolt output gone YUV, and a few solutions
I was quite surprised and disappointed to discover that many of Apple’s computers from 2011 were outputting YUV instead of RGB when using either an official Apple Mini DisplayPort to HDMI adapter or a 3rd-party direct cable from Mini DisplayPort to HDMI. (This wouldn’t matter for just about any other HDMI monitor or HDTV set, but it matters for the DreamColor Engine, as explained in several of my prior articles.) Although my contact at HP was able to solve the issue and get RGB by using a direct Mini DisplayPort to DisplayPort cable, when I tried the same thing with Rub©n AbruÃ±a, unfortunately it was still YUV (Kryptonite for the DreamColor Engine inside of the DreamColor monitor). The only way I was able to force an RGB signal from that output was to convert it to DVI, which by definition is RGB… but unfortunately is also by definition only 8-bit, and also unfortunately made the settings I had created with SwitchResX disappear. So SwitchResZ will really only be able to help you if you have previously determined that you indeed have RGB by checking to see if the DreamColor’s Engine is active (i.e. not greyed out in the DreamColor on screen menu). On top of that, I have heard from AJA that even when using Apple’s official Mini DisplayPort to HDMI adapter, it drops to 8-bit regardless. I must clarify that 10-bit (aka 30-bit) monitoring is only one of many advantages of using a DreamColor monitor… but ideally we’d want to take full advantage of the 10-bit (30-bit) feature too. So the direct Mini DisplayPort to DisplayPort cable is the best option for a Mac whose only output is Mini DisplayPort (or Thunderbolt), but it still requires trying to see whether with your particular Mac it will provide RGB to your DreamColor monitor. The low cost of that direct Mini DisplayPort to DisplayPort cable is so low that it is certainly worth a try.
Retina MacBook Pro’s new HDMI output: Is it kosher for DreamColor?
You may know that starting with the new version of the MacBook Pro with Retina display (June 2012), there is finally a direct HDMI output. Several ProVideo Coalition readers have written to me to ask whether this output is kosher for DreamColor. Unfortunately, I don’t have the answer yet, nor do my contacts at HP. We have requested a loaner unit of one of the new MacBook Pros with Retina, but it may take several weeks until we have the answer. At that point, we’ll be able to answer the key questions:
- Does the Retina MacBook Pro’s new HDMI deliver RGB (or only YUV)?
- If so, what framerates does it offer when connected to the DreamColor monitor?
- If not all of the desired framerates, does SwitchResX work well with this output to add the missing framerates while maintaining the RGB output over HDMI?
- Finally, is that output 10-bit?
Please stand by as we are able to get these answers to you. If any reader already has both devices, contact me here.
Will AJA’s upcoming T-TAP be the messiah for the DreamColor (for those who otherwise don’t need a full i/o… and are not planning to use DaVinci Resolve in its full capacity)?
As stated in several previous articles, if you plan to use DaVinci Resolve to grade footage, you at least need a Blackmagic i/o, and then (until they remove the “Band-Aid”), an additional converter called HDLink Pro 3D DisplayPort in order to see a full-screen rendering of DaVinci Resolve’s output on a DreamColor monitor. On the other hand, if you are content to see the graded video only in its preview window (as opposed to full screen in a dedicated monitor), you may be able to connect the DreamColor directly to the Mac, as long as you can get around the RGB and framerate issues mentioned above.
For popular pro apps, your solution is likely to come with AJA’s T-TAP. However, a recent followup set of emails with AJA’s PR department revealed that they are not yet ready to release a list of supported pro apps for T-TAP, and they are not yet ready to confirm whether T-TAP will offer a “desktop” mode, to be used for general tutorials or pro apps that are not directly supported, like (presumably) Adobe’s SpeedGrade or (in its preview window only) DaVinci Resolve.
To make sure you continue to see my upcoming articles, sign up to my mailing list here.
Related DreamColor articles
- Allan T©pper's: AJA announces T-TAP, the US$249 palm-sized, self-powered bridge from Thunderbolt to HDMI or SDI
- Allan T©pper's: Does Premiere CS5 achieve the "impossible dream" for critical evaluation monitoring?
- Allan T©pper's: Why should I care if my monitor shows ITU Rec.709?
- Allan T©pper's: Who is the ITU, and why should I care?
- Allan T©pper's: How to connect your HD evaluation monitor to your editing system properly: Let me count the ways!
- Allan T©pper's review: DreamColor from HP: an ideal tool for critical image evaluation
- Patrick Inhofer's review: HP's DreamColor: A PVM CRT Replacement?
- Allan T©pper's: DreamColor direct interfaces
- Allan T©pper's: DreamColor converter boxes for non-compliant systems
- Allan T©pper's: Matrox's original MXO crashes the Direct DreamColor interface party from January 10, 2010
- Art Adam's: GEEK OUT: The Non-Technical Technical Guide to Sony OLED Monitors from March 6, 2012
- Allan T©pper’s Bandito Brothers use multiple HP DreamColors + Adobe Premiere for Act of Valor from March 9, 2012
- Blackmagic: We're ready to remove the Band-Aid!
My latest ebook
I have just published an ebook in two languages.
The format is Kindle, but even if you don’’’t have a Kindle device, you can read Kindle books on many other devices using a free Kindle app. That includes iPad, iPhone, Android phones, Android tablets, Mac computers, Windows computers, some Blackberry phones and Windows 7 phones.
In English, it is currently available in the following Amazon stores, depending upon your region:
- At Amazon.com (for all of the Americas)
- Amazon.co.uk (United Kingdom)
- Amazon.de (Germany)
- Amazon.es (Spain, pero a lo mejor lo prefieres en castellano, a continuaciÃ³n)
- Amazon.fr (France)
- Amazon.it (Italy)
If you’re going to buy a Kindle book as a gift, you must do so via the Pan-American Amazon store (the first one listed above), regardless of where you live or where the recipient lives.
En castellano, estÃ¡ disponible actualmente en las siguientes tiendas Amazon, segÃºn tu regiÃ³n:
- Amazon.com (todas las Am©ricas)
- Amazon.co.uk (Reino Unido)
- Amazon.de (Alemania)
- Amazon.es (EspaÃ±a)
- Amazon.fr (Francia)
- Amazon.it (Italia)
Si vas a comprar un libro Kindle como regalo, debes hacerlo vÃa la tienda panamericana de Amazon (la primera de la lista) sin importar donde vivas tÃº o donde viva la persona que recibirÃ¡ el regalo.
Allan T©pper's books, consulting, articles, seminars & audio programs
Contact Allan T©pper for consulting, or find a full listing of his books, articles and upcoming seminars and webinars at AllanTepper.com. Listen to his TecnoTur program, which is now available both in Castilian (aka "Spanish") and in English, free of charge. Search for TecnoTur in iTunes or visit TecnoTur.us for more information.
Disclosure, to comply with the FTC's rules
No manufacturer is specifically paying Allan T©pper or TecnoTur LLC to write this article or the mentioned books. Some of the other manufacturers listed above have contracted T©pper and/or TecnoTur LLC to carry out consulting and/or translations/localizations/transcreations. Many of the manufacturers listed above have sent Allan T©pper review units. So far, none of the manufacturers listed above is/are sponsors of the TecnoTur programs, although they are welcome to do so, and some are, may be (or may have been) sponsors of ProVideo Coalition magazine. Some links to third parties listed in this article and/or on this web page may indirectly benefit TecnoTur LLC via affiliate programs.
Copyright and use of this article
The articles contained in the TecnoTur channel in ProVideo Coalition magazine are copyright Allan T©pper/TecnoTur LLC, except where otherwise attributed. Unauthorized use is prohibited without prior approval, except for short quotes which link back to this page, which are encouraged!
Get articles like this in your inbox: Sign Up
freshdv - Tue, May 21 2013 - 7:10 pm
RT @THR: Wife of 'Nashville' Crewmember Questions 'Emotional Toll' of Industry Work http://t.co/NyLkT5NKQQ
freshdv - Tue, May 21 2013 - 6:56 pm
RT @VisualEdgeChris: Fascinating article. MT: “@abelcine: Wondering how much a #4K workflow might cost you? @julietverni breaks it down! http://t.co/azTQRQ4BE6”