My biggest concern with the Gearnex is wear: that worm & sector gear system is exposed to the elements (e.g., dust), so even if there’s no backlash at first, there’s likely to be after it’s been used a bit. Did Mr. Allen address that issue? Will we want to have fabric sleeves around the workings, and liberal applications of high-pressure lithium grease after every ten hours of operation?
Posted by Adam Wilt on 05/05 at 08:29 PM
I believe he said that the new design will enclose a lot of the moving parts. Those are good questions, though. I hope I get the chance to find out.
Posted by Art Adams on 05/05 at 08:40 PM
Adam,
Thank you for the question, that same question was brought up to us at NAB with our beta units. So, Bret and I have addressed the issue in the production run units by using a cover for the worm gear below the rocker.
Posted by GearNex on 05/05 at 09:04 PM
Adam’s idea on the grease is a good idea. The whole idea of grease is that there really is no metal to metal contact between the gear surfaces. The physical contact that would wear the gears over time is actually left to the contact between the gears riding on the fluid hydraulic film between the metal surfaces of the gears.
Posted by lightprism on 05/06 at 09:08 AM
I was there at NAB and tried it out, there was hesitation at the start and finish of operation and I felt momentum during a full rotation (certain parts of the 360 were easier than others, resulting in uneven speed). Have those two issues been addressed?
Posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) on 05/06 at 05:10 PM
I brought those up myself (there’s a bump and hesitation at either end, and there’s a section of rotation where the cradle moves a little less easily than others) and Bret told me repeatedly (because I mentioned them several times!) that those were among the issues they’re working on.
They rushed three heads through production (named “Larry,” “Curly” and “Moe”) just to have something to show at CineGear. Now they’re taking all the feedback they’ve gotten and putting it into the final product. They’ve promised to ship in six weeks so they have their work cut out for them, but I think they’re going to pull it off. I plan to get my hands on one as soon as it comes off the line, and I’ll be a bit more critical of the finished product than I was of the prototype.
Posted by Art Adams on 05/06 at 05:27 PM
Art is correct, here is the time issue we had in a nutshell. We got the Beta units off the production line Thursday night before the NAB 2009 show. We started the assembly of unit #1 aka “Larry” on Friday and it took all day because it was the very first unit assembled. We tried to tune it Friday night for about 2 hours because I was leaving to Las Vegas so AJA could have the unit Saturday as requested. Unit #2 aka “Moe” & #3 “Curly” where assembled, not tuned, all day Saturday, then arrived in Las Vegas at 4 pm. We had part of the night to tune them up unlike unit #1.
By the time CineGear is here, we will have had a lot more time to tune them properly and burr the gears. We have even added many more bells and whistles for those who purchased them, we can’t wait to surprise them. Thanks for the feedback.
Posted by GearNex on 05/06 at 11:16 PM
Art
I worked on the AJA demo unit for the better part of NAB that week and I too would like to second your comments.
I see this not only for the RED community but also for all of the smaller camera users (EX, HVX, JVC) that really want to purchase a professional style product with out the bounty on gearheads from Arri and Worrell, which are engineered for much heavier cameras and accessories.
gary
Posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) on 05/07 at 07:48 AM
““Cable-driven gear heads such as the Worrall and Mini-Worrall can develop play where the wheels have to be turned a bit before they “catch” and the head responds”“
Where did you get that Worralls are cable driven? I can very wholeheartedly assure you that they are not cable driven. The Worrall head is the most solid gearhead you can get. It handles a fully tricked out RED with 80-200 Zoom no problem. Visual Products has one for $4900
Posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) on 07/28 at 06:26 AM
Here is a great story about the inventor of the Worral Head: http://worrallgrindingco.com/founder.htm
Posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) on 07/28 at 07:39 AM