(Page 1 of 2 pages for this article 1 2 >)
Sunday, October 19, 2008
Building Good Hardware (is Harder Than it Looks)
Matt Jeppsen | 10/19
Product Hype and The Cibola Complex
Building good hardware is not a trivial undertaking. We’ve all seen it time and time again as new companies go through the throes of taking a great concept all the way through the many layers of design and development, to a final shipping product (unfortunately, not always in quantity). We saw this play out for Red Digital Cinema, with their months of revised shipping target dates and hardware changes. Sony dealt with it when they had to fix widespread lens issues shortly after the EX1 launch. Even the mighty Apple has faltered recently with the somewhat buggy launch of the iPhone 3G revision. I’ll say it again; building good hardware is not an easy task. Even while companies miss the mark, what’s is interesting to me is that rarely is the original idea a bad one. In this article I’d like to take a look at several recent product launches from “indie-centric” companies. I’ll also discuss the reservations and deposits business model, a practice that seems to be largely constrained to these small businesses. I’ll sometimes casually refer to this as the “Red-servations” model of business. Obviously the concept of taking reservations in advance wasn’t innovated by Red Digital Cinema, but they really put it on the map with the development of the Red One camera. Read on…
I should start by saying that when these small indie companies get it right, the final shipping product is often a work of art and artful engineering. In most cases these products fill a niche that previously had no affordable solution. But often the time to bring that product to market is months (or years). And this long development cycle seems to be exacerbated by the current trend of taking reservations well in advance, and moreso by hyping a product that doesn’t yet exist outside of the design phase.
Let’s take a few moments and consider Redrock Micro’s launch of the microMattebox product. I’ve chosen Redrock as an example not to pick on them, but because the finished product in question is a fantastic one, and arguably worth the wait. Nevertheless, let’s deconstruct the development cycle of the microMattebox. The product was initially announced prior to NAB 2007, in fact FreshDV had one of the first interviews with Redrock’s Brian Valente on the topic. At the NAB expo a few months later Redrock showed off a rapid-prototype’d plastic mockup. The design was compelling, and the projected price point and specs sounded great. Later in the fall of that year, the company announced that they would be taking reservations and that those on the list would get the shipping product in a first-come-first served model. As you can imagine, this created quite a buzz in the online community. In November of 2007, Redrock announced that shipments of the mattebox to reservation holders were “targeted for delivery in late December” (of 2007), with general order shipments to be available “in the January/February timeframe.” At this time they also required a small deposit to retain a place in the reservations list. Geeks everywhere wet their collective pants and giggled like schoolgirls (well I did anyway).
Cut to months later at NAB 2008, and Redrock showed off what appeared to be the final version of the mattebox, stating that reservation orders would begin shipping immediately, and general orders within 60 days. Following NAB 2008, Redrock took the advice and feedback from a few beta testers and decided to re-engineer a few key facets of the design, resulting in an excellent final shipping product (at a brilliant price point). All this time, there were very few official announcements and updates provided. Near as I can figure, matteboxes did not begin shipping in quantity to reservation holders until sometime in July, and non-reservation orders didn’t begin shipping until after August 8 (this date per a Redrock announcement). That “general availability” date is nearly a year after the reservations were first opened, and a good 18 months from the initial product announcement. You can imagine the frustration that some users have vented at this long development cycle, particularly since so many deadlines were slipped in the process. The good news is that Redrock appears to have brought a brilliant product to market. While FreshDV has not tested the unit to date, most of the user reports we are hearing are very positive. Even with a protracted development schedule, it appears that Redrock Micro listened to the needs of the community, and delivered an affordable and feature-rich solution to filmmakers.
So why my beef with lead times and long-term reservations? Read on and I’ll explain…
(Page 1 of 2 pages for this article 1 2 >)
You must be registered to comment. This is an effort to reduce spam. Please REGISTER HERE.
3 comments:
1. differentiate between our involvement in the IDEA they are developing, and our getting the MANUFACTURED RESULT of the idea…
Obviously, Red, et al, are big on the Idea, and abysmal on the execution…
2. this spineless you identify, grown among our entire world, is a result of marketing-world, and also a result of removing concrete experience from “education”.
Someone who HAS no experience of making things, *cannot* know the amount of work/time involved in the making.
Someone who has no experience making, whose only knowing of making is what *marketing* pumps into their mind, has no *basis* for understanding, no connection with reality itself! in relation to making.
3. This new way is much more inclusive than the old cathedral-way of “authorized idea-contributors, only”, and the innovations are huger, thereby.
( part of the reason for the Canon/Nikon mount in the new Red system is because I pointed out to ‘em, right at the beginning, that with such a thing, they could get the Tilt-Shift lenses on their cameras, to do things that no competitor could match )
The antidote, for anyone in business & innovating, is to not only read, but to LIVE BY…
“Execution: the _discipline_ of getting things done”
http://www.amazon.com/Execution-Discipline-Getting-Things-Done/dp/0609610570/
It’s a culture, not a mere idea, and it is work, but it sweeps competition away from one’s path, excellently.
One of the necessary trainings for strong success in one’s life & career.
Cheers,
Posted by on 11/30 at 06:05 AM
|
 |
Art Adams | 06/30
Just add talent, a stolen location, natural light and a RED ONE camera
“Hey Art,” said director Ian McCamey, “I want to shoot a Facebook spec spot. I’ve got no money. Are you in?” “Of course I am,” said I. “Let’s do it.” And we did.
Ty Lowell | 06/25
Ultra-Small Millennia HD™ Records Content from HD Cameras onto Inexpensive Removable Hard Drives or Flash Disk Media
DVEO, the broadcast division of CMI, today announced the release of their new multi-function compact H.264/AVC digital disk recorder (DDR) with both removable 120 GB hard drive and CF card storage. …
Ty Lowell | 06/25
Wohler Site Is Convenient, Cost-Effective Source for Additional or Replacement Audio and Video Systems With Full Warranties
Wohler Technologies Inc. announced the launch of Wohler Online (http://www.wohleronline.com), a new Web site that makes end-of-life and refurbished products available at significantly reduced prices. Wohler Online is designed to provide dealers, integrators, and customers with a convenient and cost-effective means of replacing damaged equipment or expanding existing installations with more units…
|
|
|
|